Skip to content

Cost

Manual vs automated ad-break marking: how to work out the cost

Manual cost is hours of video times minutes of work per hour, times a loaded hourly rate. Automation swaps most of that for a per-hour price plus a shorter human review. The only reliable inputs are your own, so time ten representative titles and compare. This guide gives both formulas, a worked example with stated assumptions and a free calculator.

Published

The manual cost formula

Manual marking
manual cost = hours of video × minutes per hour of video ÷ 60 × loaded hourly rate
  • Hours of video: the running time you need marked, not the number of titles.
  • Minutes per hour of video: everything a person spends on it, including QC, rework and entering the markers into your system.
  • Loaded hourly rate: salary plus benefits and overhead, or the contractor rate. Use the cost to you, not the pay slip.

Measure your own minutes

Published figures for how long marking takes vary by content, tooling and standard, so treat any number you read, including ours, as a prompt to measure. Pick ten titles that represent your library, such as a few genres and lengths. For each one, time three things separately: the first pass, the QC pass and entering the markers. Divide by the running time of each title and look at the average and the spread.

The automated cost formula

Automated marking with review
service cost = hours of video × price per hour
review cost  = hours of video × review minutes per hour ÷ 60 × loaded hourly rate
total        = service cost + review cost

Automation does not remove the person. A person can still accept a break or set it aside before the marker goes out, so the formula keeps a review term. AdBreak pricing starts from $0.70 / €0.70 per hour of video and falls as monthly volume grows. No tier breakpoints are published, so ask for a price for your volume.

A worked example, with made-up inputs

The inputs below are assumptions chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not benchmarks or customer results; replace every one of them with your own.

Example: 500 hours of video
LineAssumptionResult
Manual marking30 minutes per hour of video, $40 per hour loaded500 × 30 ÷ 60 = 250 hours of work, $10,000
Automated service$0.70 per hour of video500 × 0.70 = $350
Automated review10 minutes per hour of video, $40 per hour loaded500 × 10 ÷ 60 = 83.3 hours of work, $3,333
Automated totalService plus review$3,683
DifferenceManual minus automated$6,317 in favour of automation under these assumptions

The break-even point is simple. Automation costs less when manual minutes per hour are greater than review minutes per hour plus price × 60 ÷ hourly rate. With these inputs that is 10 + 0.70 × 60 ÷ 40 = 11.05 minutes. If your people mark an hour of video faster than that, or review would take longer than marking, the formula says stay manual.

What the formula leaves out

  • Turnaround. A backlog of hundreds of hours is not only a cost; it is calendar time during which the titles earn nothing from ads.
  • Consistency. Several editors rarely place breaks the same way. Presets make the rules explicit.
  • Delivery. Writing SCTE-35, HLS markers or VMAP by hand is another step; automation can produce them from the same times.
  • Setup. Connecting storage and agreeing formats takes some effort, so run a pilot first.
  • The value of a better or worse break. It is real but hard to measure, and this page does not put a number on it.

Manual marking is still the right choice for a handful of titles, for one-off jobs where setup would cost more than it saves, and for premium content where an editor wants full creative control over each position.

How to run a fair pilot

  1. Choose five to ten titles that cover your genres and lengths.
  2. Mark them the way you do today and record the time for each stage.
  3. Run the same titles through the automated route and record the review time.
  4. Compare accepted breaks, rejected breaks and total minutes, not only cost.
  5. Put your own numbers into the calculator and decide.

If you would like to try this on a few of your titles, request a demo and price. To see how breaks are chosen, read how to find ad-break points in archive content.

Questions about this page

Keep reading

Request a pilot on your own files.

Send a few titles you have the rights to mark. Tell us whether you need pre-rolls, mid-rolls, or both, and how markers should reach you. For a large library, say so, and we will explain how files can be processed as they arrive. Pricing starts at $0.70 / €0.70 per hour of video and goes down as your monthly volume grows.